Erroneous & unwarranted

Re the EducationWorld India Engineering Institutes Rankings 2017-18 (EW May). Please note that BITS, Pilani is a multi-campus university and a single entity. Your ranking of our Hyderabad and Goa campuses separately is erroneous and unwarranted.  Kindly correct the same and issue a single cumulative rank to BITS, Pilani.  Prof. Vidya Rajesh Department of Biological Sciences BITS, Pilani (Hyderabad) Since the BITS campuses are widely separated geographically and quality of faculty, research, and placements of each campus vary widely, we decided to rate and rank BITS’ three campuses separately for the convenience of our readers — Editor   Curious methodology I am concerned about your ranking of India’s Top 50 Private B-schools (EW May), where XIME is ranked #25. It stretches credulity that the Rajagiri Centre for Business Studies (RCBS), Kochi, is ranked above us at #20. On all your parameters of assessment, we fare better. Our faculty is high-quality and students are diverse representing 20-25 states of India, with 52 percent being women, whereas in RCBS 95 percent of students are from Kerala. Re placements as well, our average start-up salaries are higher. We are a fully residential institution with student recruitment centres in Kolkata, Delhi and Pune.  In NIRF 2016 of the Union HRD ministry, RCBS was ranked #36 cf. XIME’s #30 rank. In NIRF 2017, RCBS isn’t ranked at all whereas XIME is the only private sector B-school (Karnataka and Kerala campuses) to be ranked in the Top 50. Something is evidently very wrong with your survey methodology. Prof. J. Philip President, Xavier Institute of Management & Entrepreneurship, Bangalore The EW Rankings of India’s Top 50 B-schools 2017-18 are based on the perceptions of 613 B-school faculty, 511 final year students and 122 industry representatives countrywide who rated and ranked them on 11 parameters of education excellence — Editor   Designation error Thanks for ranking ICFAI Business School (IBS) in your cover story of India’s Top 50 private B-schools (EW May). However, Dr. Venkata Seshaiah is the director — not dean — of the ICFAI Business School. Ramana Murthy ICFAI Group, Hyderabad   Selective disservice Your logic behind ranking only the country’s private universities, engineering institutes and B-schools is flawed and biased in favour of the privileged and elite (EW May). Most of the private universities you have ranked — Manipal, Ashoka, etc — charge hefty and unreasonable fees which are unaffordable by the majority of the population. Though I’m not advocating shutdown of private universities, your selective rankings of the country’s private institutions of higher education gives readers a one-sided view of Indian education.  My advice and request to you is to rank all institutions — government, aided and private — inter se to enable students to make informed higher education admission choices. Sukumar Banerjee Delhi   Modi government failures Re your editorial ‘Modi government’s forgotten promise’ (EW May), I agree with you that it’s time prime minister Modi delivers on his promise of ‘minimum government, maximum governance’. He has failed to fulfill his promise of improving the…